Jonathan Shifren
Doctor at Wave Plastic Surgery who received a Public Letter of Reprimand from the Medical Board of California in 2021
Does breast-augmentation surgery.
JONATHAN DAVID SHIFREN
SLAPP LAWSUIT
Case Number: 23STCV01252
WAVE PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER, INC., ET AL. VS LEZLYE ORTIZ
Filing Courthouse: Stanley Mosk Courthouse
Filing Date: 01/19/2023
Case Type: Defamation (slander/libel) (General Jurisdiction)
Status: Request for Dismissal – Before Trial not following ADR or more than 60 days since ADR 05/19/2023
PARTY INFORMATION
LEE BEN – Respondent
LEE BEN – Plaintiff
MACKAY SASSAN AMIR – Attorney for Plaintiff
ORTIZ LEZLYE – Defendant
ORTIZ LEZLYE – Appellant
SHIFREN JONATHAN – Respondent
SHIFREN JONATHAN – Plaintiff
SYVERSON ERIK SWEN – Attorney for Defendant
WAVE PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER INC. – Plaintiff
WAVE PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER INC. – Respondent
CASE INFORMATION
Case Number: 23STCV01252
WAVE PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER, INC., ET AL. VS LEZLYE ORTIZ
Filing Courthouse: Stanley Mosk Courthouse
Filing Date: 01/19/2023
Case Type: Defamation (slander/libel) (General Jurisdiction)
Status: Request for Dismissal – Before Trial not following ADR or more than 60 days since ADR 05/19/2023
PARTY INFORMATION
LEE BEN – Respondent
LEE BEN – Plaintiff
MACKAY SASSAN AMIR – Attorney for Plaintiff
ORTIZ LEZLYE – Defendant
ORTIZ LEZLYE – Appellant
SHIFREN JONATHAN – Respondent
SHIFREN JONATHAN – Plaintiff
SYVERSON ERIK SWEN – Attorney for Defendant
WAVE PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER INC. – Plaintiff
WAVE PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER INC. – Respondent
DOCUMENTS FILED
Documents Filed (Filing dates listed in descending order)
07/26/2023 Appeal – Remittitur – Appeal Dismissed (B328013)
Filed by Clerk
05/24/2023 Appeal – Notice of Non-Compliance (NOA 3/17/23 B328013)
Filed by Clerk
05/18/2023 Request for Dismissal
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
04/14/2023 Declaration (OF SASSAN MACKAY, ESQ., IN SUPPORT OF MOTION AND MOTION OF PLAINTIFFS WAVE PLASTIC SURGERY, INC., BEN LEE, AND JONATHAN SHIFREN FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE SECTION 425.16)
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
04/14/2023 Motion for Attorney Fees
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
04/10/2023 Appeal – Notice of Default Issued (NOA 03/17/23)
Filed by Clerk
03/23/2023 Appeal – Notice of Filing of Notice of Appeal
Filed by Clerk
03/17/2023 Appeal – Notice of Appeal/Cross Appeal Filed
Filed by Lezlye Ortiz (Appellant)
03/07/2023 Court’s Ruling on Motion to Strike
Filed by Clerk
03/07/2023 Certificate of Mailing for ((Hearing on Special Motion to Strike under CCP Section 425.16 …) of 03/07/2023)
Filed by Clerk
03/07/2023 Minute Order ( (Hearing on Special Motion to Strike under CCP Section 425.16 …))
Filed by Clerk
02/28/2023 Declaration (OF ERIK SYVERSON IN SUPPORT OF REPLY BRIEF)
Filed by Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
02/28/2023 Reply (DEFENDANT LEZLYE ORTIZ?S REPLY BRIEF; DECLARATION OF ERIK SYVERSON FILED UNDER SEPARATE COVER)
Filed by Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
02/22/2023 Declaration (of Ben Lee in Support of Defendants Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp)
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
02/22/2023 Declaration (of Jonathan Shifren in Support of Defendants Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp)
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
02/22/2023 Declaration (of Sassan Mackay in Support of Defendants Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp)
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
02/22/2023 Opposition (to Defendants Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp)
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
02/22/2023 Declaration (AMENDED Declaration of Sassan Mackay in Support to Opposition to Defendant’s Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp)
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
02/22/2023 Proof of Personal Service
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
01/31/2023 Motion to Strike (not initial pleading)
Filed by Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
01/26/2023 Summons (on Complaint)
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
01/26/2023 Civil Case Cover Sheet
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
01/20/2023 Notice of Case Management Conference
Filed by Clerk
01/20/2023 Order to Show Cause Failure to File Proof of Service
Filed by Clerk
01/20/2023 Notice (of Correction of Firm Address)
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
01/19/2023 Notice of Case Assignment – Unlimited Civil Case
Filed by Clerk
01/19/2023 Voluntary Efficient Litigation Stipulation Packet
Filed by Clerk
01/19/2023 First Amended General Order re: Mandatory Electronic Filing
Filed by Clerk
01/19/2023 Alternate Dispute Resolution Packet
Filed by Clerk
01/19/2023 Civil Case Cover Sheet
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
01/19/2023 Complaint
Filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
PROCEEDINGS HELD
08/30/2023 at 09:00 AM in Department 58
Hearing on Motion for Attorney Fees – Not Held – Advanced and Continued – by Court
05/26/2023 at 08:30 AM in Department 58
Case Management Conference – Not Held – Vacated by Court
05/26/2023 at 08:30 AM in Department 58
Order to Show Cause Re: Failure to File Proof of Service – Not Held – Vacated by Court
05/24/2023 at 09:00 AM in Department 58
Hearing on Motion for Attorney Fees – Not Held – Vacated by Court
05/24/2023 at 09:00 AM in Department 58
Hearing on Motion for Attorney Fees – Not Held – Vacated by Court
03/07/2023 at 09:00 AM in Department 58, Bruce G. Iwasaki, Presiding
Hearing on Special Motion to Strike under CCP Section 425.16 (Anti-SLAPP motion) – Held
REGISTER OF ACTIONS
07/27/2023 Updated — Appeal – Remittitur – Appeal Dismissed B328013: As To Parties:
07/26/2023 Appeal – Remittitur – Appeal Dismissed B328013; Filed by: Clerk
05/24/2023 Appeal – Notice of Non-Compliance NOA 3/17/23 B328013; Filed by: Clerk
05/19/2023 On the Complaint filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc., et al. on 01/19/2023, entered Request for Dismissal with prejudice filed by Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc., Ben Lee, and Jonathan Shifren as to the entire action
05/19/2023 Hearing on Motion for Attorney Fees scheduled for 05/24/2023 at 09:00 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58 Not Held – Vacated by Court on 05/19/2023
05/19/2023 Order to Show Cause Re: Failure to File Proof of Service scheduled for 05/26/2023 at 08:30 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58 Not Held – Vacated by Court on 05/19/2023
05/19/2023 Case Management Conference scheduled for 05/26/2023 at 08:30 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58 Not Held – Vacated by Court on 05/19/2023
05/18/2023 Request for Dismissal; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff); As to: Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
04/14/2023 Motion for Attorney Fees; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
04/14/2023 Declaration OF SASSAN MACKAY, ESQ., IN SUPPORT OF MOTION AND MOTION OF PLAINTIFFS WAVE PLASTIC SURGERY, INC., BEN LEE, AND JONATHAN SHIFREN FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE SECTION 425.16; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
04/14/2023 On the Court’s own motion, Hearing on Motion for Attorney Fees scheduled for 08/30/2023 at 09:00 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58 Not Held – Advanced and Continued – by Court was rescheduled to 05/24/2023 09:00 AM
04/14/2023 Hearing on Motion for Attorney Fees scheduled for 05/24/2023 at 09:00 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58 Not Held – Vacated by Court on 04/14/2023
04/14/2023 Hearing on Motion for Attorney Fees scheduled for 05/24/2023 at 09:00 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58
04/10/2023 Appeal – Notice of Default Issued NOA 03/17/23; Filed by: Clerk
03/23/2023 Appeal – Notice of Filing of Notice of Appeal; Filed by: Clerk
03/17/2023 Appeal – Notice of Appeal/Cross Appeal Filed; Filed by: Lezlye Ortiz (Appellant); As to: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Respondent); Ben Lee (Respondent); Jonathan Shifren (Respondent); To be paid at Central: No
03/07/2023 Hearing on Motion for Attorney Fees scheduled for 05/24/2023 at 09:00 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58
03/07/2023 Court’s Ruling on Motion to Strike; Filed by: Clerk
03/07/2023 Updated — Court’s Ruling on Motion to Strike: Result Date: 03/07/2023 ; As To Parties:
03/07/2023 Minute Order (Hearing on Special Motion to Strike under CCP Section 425.16 …)
03/07/2023 Certificate of Mailing for (Hearing on Special Motion to Strike under CCP Section 425.16 …) of 03/07/2023; Filed by: Clerk
03/07/2023 Updated — Erik Swen Syverson (Attorney): Organization Name: The Syverson Law Firm
03/07/2023 Hearing on Special Motion to Strike under CCP Section 425.16 (Anti-SLAPP motion) scheduled for 03/07/2023 at 09:00 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58 updated: Result Date to 03/07/2023; Result Type to Held
02/28/2023 Reply DEFENDANT LEZLYE ORTIZ’S REPLY BRIEF; DECLARATION OF ERIK SYVERSON FILED UNDER SEPARATE COVER; Filed by: Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
02/28/2023 Declaration OF ERIK SYVERSON IN SUPPORT OF REPLY BRIEF; Filed by: Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
02/22/2023 Proof of Personal Service; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff); As to: Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant); Service Date: 01/26/2023; Service Cost Waived: No
02/22/2023 Declaration AMENDED Declaration of Sassan Mackay in Support to Opposition to Defendant’s Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
02/22/2023 Opposition to Defendants Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
02/22/2023 Declaration of Sassan Mackay in Support of Defendants Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
02/22/2023 Declaration of Jonathan Shifren in Support of Defendants Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
02/22/2023 Declaration of Ben Lee in Support of Defendants Special Motion to Strike Anti Slapp; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
01/31/2023 Motion to Strike (not initial pleading); Filed by: Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
01/31/2023 Hearing on Special Motion to Strike under CCP Section 425.16 (Anti-SLAPP motion) scheduled for 03/07/2023 at 09:00 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58
01/26/2023 Civil Case Cover Sheet; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
01/26/2023 Summons on Complaint; Issued and Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff); As to: Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
01/24/2023 Address for Sassan Amir Mackay (Attorney) updated
01/24/2023 Address for Sassan Amir Mackay (Attorney) updated
01/24/2023 Address for Sassan Amir Mackay (Attorney) updated
01/20/2023 Case Management Conference scheduled for 05/26/2023 at 08:30 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58
01/20/2023 Notice of Case Management Conference; Filed by: Clerk
01/20/2023 Case assigned to Hon. Bruce G. Iwasaki in Department 58 Stanley Mosk Courthouse
01/20/2023 Notice of Correction of Firm Address; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff); As to: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff)
01/20/2023 Order to Show Cause Failure to File Proof of Service; Filed by: Clerk
01/20/2023 Order to Show Cause Re: Failure to File Proof of Service scheduled for 05/26/2023 at 08:30 AM in Stanley Mosk Courthouse at Department 58
01/19/2023 Complaint; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff); As to: Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
01/19/2023 Civil Case Cover Sheet; Filed by: Wave Plastic Surgery Center, Inc. (Plaintiff); Ben Lee (Plaintiff); Jonathan Shifren (Plaintiff); As to: Lezlye Ortiz (Defendant)
01/19/2023 Alternate Dispute Resolution Packet; Filed by: Clerk
01/19/2023 First Amended General Order re: Mandatory Electronic Filing; Filed by: Clerk
01/19/2023 Voluntary Efficient Litigation Stipulation Packet; Filed by: Clerk
01/19/2023 Notice of Case Assignment – Unlimited Civil Case; Filed by: Clerk